Appendix

Appendix A

References & Citations

[1] John Kania, Mark Kramer, Peter Senge, “The Water of Systems Change,” FSG, 2018.

[2] Race Forward, “Principles for Racially Equitable Policy Platforms,” 2020.

[3] Emily Orminski, “Your Zip Code Is More Important Than Your Genetic Code,” National Community Reinvestment Coalition, 2021.

[4] Raj Chetty, Nathaniel Hendren, and Lawrence F. Katz Harvard, “The Effects of Exposure to Better Neighborhoods on Children: New Evidence from the Moving to Opportunity Experiment,” University and NBER, 2015.

[5] Mindy Fullilove, “Root Shock: How Tearing Up City Neighborhoods Hurts America, And What We Can Do About It,” 2004.

[6] Partners for Dignity & Rights and Race Forward, “Co-Governing Toward Multiracial Democracy,” Race Forward, 2023

[7] See “Co-Governing Toward Multiracial Democracy,” Partners for Dignity & Rights and Race Forward.

Appendix B

Member Charter

Central Providence Unidos’ Member Charter was approved by the Executive Committee and implemented in 2025.

Summary

Central Providence Unidos is a place-based comprehensive initiative aimed at increasing economic mobility and health equity across Central Providence. Our vision is that all residents of Central Providence will live healthy, stable lives and be empowered to impact the conditions in their community. To this end, Central Providence Unidos invests operational, financial, and political capital into efforts that meet residents’ foundational needs, increases access to drivers of mobility, and builds local power and capacity, which together advance health, racial and economic equity so that the conditions that drive health and economic disparities will improve. This vision and theory of change is outlined in greater detail in the Central Providence Roadmap (the Roadmap), a 10-year vision for collective community impact.

To achieve equitable outcomes and deep systems-level change, our work must be collaborative, and our key strategic decisions made by community members who live and work in Central Providence. This Charter is intended to formalize roles across Central Providence Unidos so that each member may better understand their role within Central Providence Unidos and their power to inform and/or make decisions on behalf Central Providence Unidos.

Central Providence Unidos Equity Commitment

While year-to-year priorities, programmatic operations, and advocacy strategies will change according to context and need, Central Providence Unidos commits to holding racial equity at the center of everything we do. All members of Central Providence Unidos agree to uphold this commitment to equity as outlined in the Central Providence Roadmap.

Central Providence Unidos Backbone (One Neighborhood Builders)

One Central Providence, a team within One Neighborhood Builders, convenes Central Providence Unidos and facilitates the implementation of the Central Providence Roadmap. By serving as the backbone of Central Providence Unidos, One Central Providence brings to bear the community development expertise and strong administration of One Neighborhood Builders while providing a supportive and invested entity for the purposes of convening and resource development.

Collaborative Members

Collaborative members are residents, community groups, businesses, government agencies, and other partners who are stakeholders in Central Providence. All Collaborative members will be listed on the Central Providence Unidos website, either as an organization or as an individual. Members may also automatically be included on a list of signatories on written testimonies, letters of support, and op-eds, among other written, visual and otherwise public materials, as determined by the Executive Committee on behalf of Central Providence Unidos.

In order to formally join the Collaborative, members must agree to:

  • Attend at least one Central Providence Unidos meeting a year;
  • Broadly agree to advance North Stars as outlined in the Roadmap;
  • Align with Central Providence Unidos equity commitment as outlined in the Roadmap, both in principle and in practice;
  • Not advocate against Central Providence Unidos priorities as endorsed by the Executive Committee;
  • Complete Central Providence Unidos’ annual survey; and
  • Live in, work in, or conduct work that directly impacts Central Providence.

Membership is mutually voluntary and may be ended at any time. A Collaborative member may decide to leave Central Providence Unidos by delivering an exit letter to the Executive Committee and One Central Providence. The acceptance of the letter shall not be necessary to make it effective.

Collaborative members may also be removed from Central Providence Unidos if their mission, values and scope of work is found to be contradicting Central Providence Unidos’ equity commitment, and/or if a member does not fulfill their agreements as outlined above. After thoughtful discussion and as a last resort, the Executive Committee may democratically decide to remove an organization/individual from the Collaborative.

Collaborative members and non-members are both welcome at the bimonthly Collaborative meetings hosted by One Central Providence.

Working Group Participants

Anyone, regardless of Collaborative membership status, may attend and participate in Working Group meetings. These Working Groups, focused on the five North Stars of the Central Providence Roadmap, do the bulk of coordination and strategy work for Central Providence Unidos, though these are not the bodies that formally make decisions or endorsements. Participants do not need to formally join a Working Group, but should show up to meetings as relevant to help move the work forward and consistently engage in collaboration with Central Providence Unidos partners. Wherever possible, organizations should delegate a consistent representative to attend these Working Group meetings.

Executive Committee

The Executive Committee is the central decision-making body for Central Providence Unidos. It is comprised of the Resident Advisory Council and Strategic Advisors, both of which are described in greater detail below. The Executive Committee is charged with making decisions that affect the strategic direction and priorities of the entire Central Providence Unidos, using a set voting process and quorum rules.

Resident Advisory Council

The Resident Advisory Council (RAC) is a group of community members who either live in or have deep ties to Central Providence. The RAC is expected to:

  • Adhere to the Collaborative Member agreement as outlined above;
  • Convene on the first Tuesday of every month from 6-8p;
  • Make decisions on behalf of the Executive Committee where Strategic Advisors are not needed;
  • Elevate community priorities and provide recommendations for action for Central Providence Unidos;
    And develop their leadership and advocacy skills.

 

New RAC members will be interviewed by current members to ensure alignment with Central Providence Unidos’ mission. RAC members will serve a maximum term of three years.

RAC members will receive a $137.50 stipend for each month they participate, either in the regularly scheduled meeting or in another way as agreed upon with One Central Providence. Members will inform One Central Providence in advance of any scheduled meetings that they cannot attend.

All RAC members will be listed on the Central Providence Unidos website. Names of RAC members may also automatically be included on a list of signatories on written testimonies, letters of support, and op-eds, among other written, visual and otherwise public materials, as determined by the Executive Committee on behalf of Central Providence Unidos.

Membership is mutually voluntary and may be ended at any time. A RAC member may decide to leave CPO-HEZ by delivering an exit letter to the Executive Committee and One Central Providence. The acceptance of the letter shall not be necessary to make it effective.

RAC members may also be removed from Central Providence Unidos if their mission, values and scope of work is found to be contradicting CPO-HEZ’s equity commitment, and/or if they miss three meetings without attempting to compensate for the lost time. After thoughtful discussion, the Executive Committee may democratically decide to remove an individual from the RAC.

Strategic Advisors

The Strategic Advisors are decision-makers at Central Providence Unidos partner organizations – including nonprofits, philanthropy, and the public sector – invited by One Central Providence to:

  • Adhere to the Collaborative Member agreement as outlined above;
  • Attend quarterly Executive Committee meetings in partnership with the RAC;
  • Make decisions in partnership with the RAC where strategic input is required, as outlined in Appendix C; and
  • Provide expert guidance on Central Providence Unidos strategy and priorities as needed.

 

Membership is mutually voluntary and may be ended at any time. A Strategic Advisor may decide to leave Central Providence Unidos by delivering an exit letter to the Executive Committee and One Central Providence. The acceptance of the letter shall not be necessary to make it effective.

Strategic Advisors may also be removed from Central Providence Unidos if their mission, values and scope of work is found to be contradicting Central Providence Unidos’ equity commitment, and/or if they miss three consecutive meetings without attempting to compensate for the lost time. After thoughtful discussion, the Executive Committee may democratically decide to remove a Strategic Advisor from their leadership role in Central Providence Unidos.

Appendix C

Indicators & Definitions for Central Providence Unidos Dashboard

As we continue to learn about what public, administrative, and primary data we need to effectively analyze our impact, we will periodically update the dashboard. We used the following criteria in evaluating our choices of indicators.

  • Geographic Granularity: We will continue to make efforts to obtain neighborhood-level data to reflect Central Providence conditions accurately.
  • Data Power, Communication Power & Timeliness: Data sources must be statistically valid & seen as reputable to diverse stakeholder groups. Each indicator will be updated annually or as new datasets become available. For more details, please see the website.
  • Equity: Indicator selection prioritizes populations historically marginalized by systemic inequities.
  • Relevance: Each indicator has logical connections to the strategies and outcomes outlined in the Roadmap.
  • Bias Mitigation: Engage cross-sector stakeholders to provide qualitative context and ensure data reflects lived experiences.

Housing

% of Households that Spend ≥30% of Their Income on Housing

Definition: Percentage of households in Central Providence spending 30% or more of their income on housing costs, including rent, mortgage, utilities, and other housing expenses.

Source: American Community Survey (ACS), U.S. Census Bureau.

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Data is self-reported and subject to sampling error. Margins of error may be higher for small geographies.

Eviction Filings

Definition: Total number of eviction cases filed in local courts within the Central Providence region.

Source: Eviction Lab, Princeton University; Rhode Island State Judiciary.

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Filings do not capture informal evictions, like self-help evictions. Data may not include cases dismissed or resolved outside court proceedings.

Low & Moderate Income Housing by Community

Definition: The percentage of year-round housing units in a community that meet the definition of low and moderate income housing as defined by Rhode Island General Law 45-53-3. This includes subsidized housing units that are deed-restricted to be affordable to households earning at or below 80% of Area Median Income (AMI).

Source: Rhode Island Housing Low and Moderate Income Housing Data; Municipal Housing Authorities; Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD)

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Data may underrepresent naturally occurring affordable housing that lacks deed restrictions or subsidies but serves low-income households. The 80% AMI threshold is calculated based on the metropolitan statistical area’s median income, which may not accurately reflect local economic conditions in specific neighborhoods. Unit counts may not capture occupancy rates, physical condition, or appropriateness of unit sizes for local housing needs. The measurement does not account for geographic distribution of affordable housing within communities, which can affect access to transportation, jobs, and services.

Health

Insurance Coverage

Definition: Insurance coverage by race, ethnicity and geography

Source: American Community Survey (ACS), U.S. Census Bureau; Rhode Island Department of Health.

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Limited granularity for populations with small numbers. Cultural and linguistic barriers may affect survey participation.

Lead Exposure  Prevalence

Definition: Percentage of children aged 0-6 years in Central Providence with elevated blood lead levels, as defined by CDC thresholds.

Source: Rhode Island Department of Health Lead Data

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Data is often underreported due to lack of universal testing. Disparities may exist based on socioeconomic and housing conditions.

ED Visit Rates for Primary DX of Asthma for Children (0-18 years)

Definition: Total count of Emergency Room visits for children in Rhode Island where the primary diagnosis was asthma.

Source: Rhode Island Department of Health Asthma Data

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: The ED Visit Rates indicator may undercount visits to out-of-state facilities and cases where asthma is a contributing but not primary diagnosis. Socioeconomic factors and environmental conditions can also create geographic variations in both asthma prevalence and care-seeking behavior.

Education

Graduation Rates for Multilingual Learners

Definition: Percentage of multilingual learners in Central Providence who graduate high school within four years.

Source:  Rhode Island Department of Education (RIDE) Graduation Data

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Data excludes students who transfer or leave the school system. Reporting may vary based on school district policies.

# of Educators Who Hold Bilingual Dual Language and World Language Certifications

Definition: Total number of educators in Central Providence public schools certified to teach bilingual, dual-language, or world language programs.

Source: Rhode Island Department of Education (RIDE).

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Certification data may not capture actual deployment in classrooms. Variability in certification standards across time.

% of Family Members of PPSD Students Who Rate Special Education Services as Favorable

Definition: Percentage of family members with children in Providence Public School District (PPSD) who report favorable opinions about special education services in annual surveys.

Source: Providence Public School District Annual Parent Surveys (RIDE Surveyworks)

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Survey response rates may be low, leading to nonresponse bias. Cultural and language barriers may influence participation.

Quality Work

Business Ownership by Race and Gender

Definition: Distribution of business ownership in Central Providence categorized by race and gender of the owner(s).

Source: U.S. Census Bureau’s Annual Business Survey (ABS)

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Self-reported data may not capture informal or unregistered businesses. Limited data availability for smaller geographies.

Employment-to-Population Ratio for Adults Aged 25-54

Definition: The ratio of the working-age population (25-54 years) in Central Providence to the share of that population that is employed.

Source: American Community Survey (ACS), U.S. Census Bureau; Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS)

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Data may underrepresent marginalized groups facing systemic barriers to employment.

How Residents Rate Job Opportunities and Job Training Programs

Definition: Percentage of residents rating job opportunities and job training programs in as favorable

Source: RI Life Index (Blue Cross & Blue Shield of Rhode Island (BCBSRI) and the Brown University School of Public Health)

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Survey results may be influenced by sampling bias or low response rates. Perceptions may vary widely based on lived experience and cultural factors.

Power

Juvenile Arrests per 100,000 Juveniles

Definition: Number of arrests of individuals under the age of 18 per 100,000 juvenile population in Central Providence.

Source: Rhode Island Department of Public Safety; FBI Uniform Crime Reporting (UCR) Program (Urban Institute, Upward Mobility Dashboard)

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Data may not account for racial profiling or inconsistencies in law enforcement practices.

% of Eligible Individuals Registered to Vote During the Last Presidential Election

Definition: Percentage of eligible individuals registered to vote.

Source: Rhode Island Board of Elections; U.S. Census Bureau Voting and Registration Data.

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Data may not reflect barriers to voter registration, such as disenfranchisement. Registration disparities may exist by race, age, and income.

Ratio of the Share of Local Elected Officials of a Racial or Ethnic Group to the Share of That Group in the Population

Definition: Ratio comparing the percentage of elected officials from a specific racial or ethnic group to their percentage in the general population of Central Providence.

Source: Local Government Records; U.S. Census Bureau; Central Providence Unidos data collection

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Disparities in representation may result from structural inequities in political access. Data may not account for intersectional identities (e.g., race and gender).

Climate Resilience

Tree Equity Score

Definition: A composite metric ranging from 0 to 100 that measures how well a neighborhood’s tree canopy serves its residents based on climate, demographics, and existing tree coverage. The score considers factors including income, employment, race, age, health data, surface temperature, and existing tree canopy.

Source: American Forests Tree Equity Score tool; Local municipal tree inventories

Notes on Representativeness and Bias: Satellite imagery used for tree canopy assessment may have seasonal limitations and varying accuracy. The composite nature of the score means changes in individual factors may be masked in the overall score. Urban heat island data may not capture microclimates or recent development changes. Demographic data used in calculations may lag behind rapid neighborhood changes. The score may not fully account for variations in tree species, age, or health.

en_USEnglish
Powered by TranslatePress